“We’re happy. We just want to thank the jury.” ~Adam “Ad-Rock” Horovitz
Beastie Boys have won a $1.7 million verdict in their copyright lawsuit against Monster Beverage over the company’s use of the group’s music in a promotional video, according to Reuters.
The group sought up to $2.5 million for copyright infringement and false endorsement, though Monster countered that the maximum amount it owed was $125,000. The company called the case “illogical,” admitting that it had infringed the group’s copyrights, but stating that an employee inadvertently believed Monster had permission to use the music.
“Although Monster Energy has great respect for the verdict of the jury, we strongly disagree with it,” Reid Kahn, attorney for Monster, tells Rolling Stone. “We will make an application to the Court to set aside the verdict and we intend to file an appeal. From the inception, Monster Energy has been willing to resolve this matter in a fair and equitable manner and we will continue to make additional efforts to reach a just resolution of this dispute.”
The group initiated the lawsuit in 2012 following the death of Adam “MCA” Yauch. The suit, filed by Mike D, Ad-Rock and Yauch’s widow Dechen, claimed that Monster included parts of “Sabotage,” “So What’cha Want,” Make Some Noise” and “Looking Down the Barrel of a Gun” in a promotional video posted on Monster’s website, along with a 23-minute medley of Beastie Boys songs made available for download as an MP3. The songs were taken from footage of a live set by DJ Z-Trip at the Monster-sponsored Canadian festival Ruckus in the Rockies, held a few days after Yauch died in May. Yauch’s will specifically prohibits any company from using the group’s music for advertisements.
According to the legal opinion dismissing Z-Trip’s involvement in the case last November, the presiding judge noted a Monster employee had sent Z-Trip a rough cut of a video using his Beastie Boys megamix. When Z-Trip replied, in part, “Dope!,” the employee interpreted that to mean he had permission to run the video on Monster’s website. Z-Trip testified that he was merely “convey[ing] that I liked how I appeared in the video.”
A bulk of the opinion was spent on defining the legal definition of the word “dope” and if it legally constituted a license for Monster to use the video. As the court notes, “In proper context, the word ‘Dope!’ could certainly be taken as an expression, albeit unorthodox, of approval and acceptance of another’s antecedent offer,” the court said. “But here, Z-Trip’s exclamation, ‘Dope!’ was in response to [the] query, ‘Please have a look at the video from this past weekend and let me know if you approve.’
“Viewed in this context, Z-Trip’s response of ‘Dope!’ plainly communicated that, in some sense, he ‘approve[d]’ of ‘the video.’ But such approval is quite distinct from conveying assent to a mutual exchange of promises or other consideration. And it certainly did not convey that Z-Trip had authority to approve, on behalf of the Beastie Boys, a free license to Monster to use the Beastie Boys’ recordings and songs.”
When asked for comment on Beastie Boys’ court victory, Z-Trip told Rolling Stone, “Dope!”
Congrats to them!
I think I listened to “Licensed to Ill” for a solid year when it first came out.
Me too. I’m dating myself here but Licensed to Ill and Radio were the first rap albums I ever purchased.
My first rap album was the 12″ copy of “Rappers Delight” by the Sugarhill Gang.
So was mine. I remember rushing home, playing it, and memorizing all the lyrics. You just brought back memories, lol.
My Lord did I love License to Ill.
I recently read that the logo Monster uses is actually arabic 666. And i notice that most arab store with the logo cut off one of the 6’s.
You coons really care about bullshit boys?
very truth hip hip is whitewashed
old white people are rapping lol
Unlike old black men. Hello Jigga! And the Beasties with the help of Rick Rubin put a whole different spin on rap. They were not like Iggy Azalea trying to sound black. They sounded white as hell. But they had a solid rock flava that was great to listen to if you like rock. I think they are pretty original.
are stupid rock and roll was invented by a black people
then white people took it and ruined it with their
heavy metal shyt
if black people do rock and roll white people will complain
that’s why white people carry on
Oh sorry Einstein. I meant that until Rick Rubin, rap had not been blended with rock. RR was the mastermind behind the Run DMC collaboration with Aerosmith and the Beastie’s sound. Okay?
Oh, and white people really complained when Jimi Hendrix and Sly Stone were rockin’. smh
clearly you are dumb!!! black people invented rock and roll not white people
look it up or ask other commentors they should tell you
Rocket 88 by Ike Turner is considered the first rock n roll track…
white people love to complain and moan about shyt
at least they got noticed
seem i got trolls on my thread
you people need to grow up
a self hating black women who double dips with white men
and a white man who wants to be black
damn the world has gone crazy
Girl what is with you and your obsession with white men? I hardly ever think of them at all, but you bring the subject up in nearly every post. either a white dude did you wrong, or you secretly want one and they aren’t interested.
For real, most grown ups don’t feel the need to conflate every freaking topic with the white man and his issues. It’s old and it’s all been said 50 times.
clearly you are obsessed with white men
i do’t bring up men that much
i do’t white men cos they age badly
you need help toy clearly for black issue your a coon
Dope. I need a Jew asap 🙂
Comments are closed.